| 1 | The Herncubs | 100.8 | W7 vs What Would Jeter Do? (154.0) | W6 vs Nylzy (65.5) |
| 2 | Mets suck | 98.0 | W9 vs The Infirmary (127.0) | W10 vs Stout (71.5) |
| 3 | The Infirmary | 94.8 | W1 vs VinScully4President (120.0) | W10 vs theee yankees win (66.0) |
| 4 | The Other Girl | 94.6 | W8 vs Stout (121.0) | W9 vs The Herncubs (59.5) |
| 5 | Nylzy | 92.4 | W5 vs Stout (122.5) | W6 vs The Herncubs (57.5) |
| 6 | Wizards of Ozzie | 92.4 | W2 vs What Would Jeter Do? (117.5) | W1 vs Nylzy (73.0) |
| 7 | The Dancing Homers | 92.0 | W10 vs What Would Jeter Do? (130.5) | W7 vs Stout (61.5) |
| 8 | Stout | 89.0 | W6 vs What Would Jeter Do? (137.0) | W3 vs VinScully4President (58.5) |
| 9 | The Return of Sandy Novaxx | 88.8 | W9 vs theee yankees win (142.0) | W5 vs The Dancing Homers (52.0) |
| 10 | VinScully4President | 87.5 | W2 vs Goshankster (115.5) | W8 vs Wizards of Ozzie (57.5) |
| 11 | Dick Beard | 85.8 | W12 vs The Infirmary (126.0) | W11 vs The Return of Sandy Novaxx (56.5) |
| 12 | Goshankster | 83.0 | W11 vs Nylzy (138.0) | W5 vs Wizards of Ozzie (46.5) |
| 13 | What Would Jeter Do? | 82.8 | W10 vs The Dancing Homers (120.0) | W4 vs The Return of Sandy Novaxx (46.0) |
| 14 | theee yankees win | 78.0 | W5 vs Mets suck (108.5) | W2 vs The Dancing Homers (37.5) |